Location Referencing: documentation and specification Inconsistency about country code ccd

Submitted by Fabrizio.Paoletti on Monday, 7 September, 2015 - 15:59
Issue ID
201
Component
UML Location Referencing
Category
Bug report
Priority
Normal
Status
Submitted
Source
ES5
Description

An inconsistency has been found in documentation provided on website, since version 1.0 in example messages and User Guide about Alert C Location coding Country Code

 

In Alert C Method for AlertCLinear, AlertCPoint and AlertCArea Classes the same attribute alertCLocationCountryCode  has definition "EBU country code"

 

The UserGuide ( DATEXIIv2.0-UserGuide.pdf ) for Alert C report to use 'F' for France

 

we assume the reference in mind is the EN 50067 which contains the definition for usage of COuntry Codes in RDS ( and extended country codes out of Europe ) which map E for Sweden and Spain and F for France (http://www.interactive-radio-system.com/docs/EN50067_RDS_Standard.pdf pag 70 and 71 )

 

in the provided examples such code is otherwise managed in different ways  ( since Version 1.0 to the current version )

 

- in example Situation Record Accident we find alertCLocationCountryCode = E for sweden feed

- in example file for Travel Time we found 14 in example from France 

- in example for Itinerary we find both Code E and 14  ( and incidentally version is further defined as "2.1" or "2.0" while it should be an integer in TMC coding despite the datatype is valid as it is String )

 

otherwise searching the web for "EBU country codes" lead to https://tech.ebu.ch/docs/tech/tech3279.pdf which base its definition to ISO alha 2 country codes.

 

same concern is about alertCLocationTableNumber which in the user guide is identified with 32 and in the examples from Sweden is 33 and also for France is the same.. while we had assumed in the past it was the Location Table number defined in the country, which for Italy we would provide as 1

after discussion in TG it seems that the correct reference for CC is EN 50067 so we assume this should be improved in definition and updated in example messages and guides

Found Version
{"changeLogs":[{"date":1528366531641,"componentOLD":"- Select a value -","component":"UML Location Referencing","categoryOLD":"- Select a value -","category":"Bug report","priorityOLD":"- None -","priority":"Normal","statusOLD":"- None -","status":"Submitted"},{"date":1537266914689}]}

Posted by iancornwell on June 22, 2022 Permalink

Discussed at Oporto TG and agreed that the model should not change.
Call on 3/12 agreed this should be reassigned to documentation.